| 6 | H Yarnold | Worcestershire v Scotland | Forthill, Dundee | 1951 |
| 5 | G Ubsdell | Hampshire v Surrey | Day's (Antelope) Ground, Southampton | 1865 |
| 5 | EW Pooley | Surrey v Lancashire | Kennington Oval, Kennington | 1868 |
| 5 | R Pilling | Lancashire v Nottinghamshire | Old Trafford, Manchester | 1878 |
| 5 | EW Pooley | Surrey v Kent | Kennington Oval, Kennington | 1878 |
| 5 | JM Blackham | Victoria v Lord Harris' XI | Melbourne Cricket Ground, Melbourne | 1878/79 |
| 5 | G MacGregor | Middlesex v Nottinghamshire | Trent Bridge, Nottingham | 1902 |
| 5 | NC Tufnell | Cambridge University v Yorkshire | FP Fenner's Ground, Cambridge | 1909 |
| 5 | FH Huish | Kent v Surrey | Kennington Oval, Kennington | 1911 |
| 5 | D Tallon | Queensland v Marylebone Cricket Club | Brisbane Cricket Ground, Woolloongabba, Brisbane | 1935/36 |
| 5 | MO Srinivasan | Madras v Madras Governor's XI | Madras Cricket Club Ground, Chepauk, Madras | 1941/42 |
| 5 | EA Baker | Victoria v New South Wales | Sydney Cricket Ground, Sydney | 1946/47 |
| 5 | G Atma Singh | Services v Delhi | Feroz Shah Kotla, Delhi | 1954/55 |
| 5 | BA Barnett | Commonwealth XI v England XI | Central Recreation Ground, Hastings | 1960 |
| 5 | G Ghosh | Bihar v Orissa | Barabati Stadium, Cuttack | 1965/66 |
| 5 | KS More | India v West Indies | MA Chidambaram Stadium, Chepauk, Madras | 1987/88 |
| 5 | KK Patel | Madhya Pradesh v Railways | Palam A Ground, Model Sports Complex, Delhi | 1992/93 |
| 5 | EAD Ashan | Kalutara Physical Culture Centre v Panadura Sports Club | Surrey Village Cricket Ground, Maggona | 2016/17 |
| 4 | Elyard | Lord F Beauclerk's XI v W Barton's XI | Aram's New Ground, Montpelier Gardens, Walworth | 1802 |
| 4 | J Hammond | England v Surrey | Lord's Old Ground, Marylebone | 1803 |
| 4 | J Hammond | Marylebone Cricket Club v England | Lord's Old Ground, Marylebone | 1807 |
| 4 | EH Budd | Gentlemen v Players | Lord's Cricket Ground, St John's Wood | 1819 |
| 4 | J Barnard | Marylebone Cricket Club v Godalming | Lord's Cricket Ground, St John's Wood | 1822 |
| 4 | W Slater | Players v Gentlemen | Lord's Cricket Ground, St John's Wood | 1824 |
| 4 | T Flavel | Godalming v Marylebone Cricket Club | The Burys, Godalming | 1825 |
| 4 | W Broadbridge | Sussex v Hampshire and Surrey | Bramshill Park, Bramshill | 1826 |
| 4 | E Stephenson | Yorkshire v Surrey | Kennington Oval, Kennington | 1864 |
| 4 | E Stephenson | Yorkshire v Nottinghamshire | Great Horton Road, Bradford | 1864 |
| 4 | HW Fellows | Gentlemen of Marylebone Cricket Club v Gentlemen of Kent | St Lawrence Ground, Canterbury | 1865 |
| 4 | W Nicholson | Gentlemen of Marylebone Cricket Club v Kent | St Lawrence Ground, Canterbury | 1867 |
| 4 | EW Pooley | Surrey v Cambridge University | Kennington Oval, Kennington | 1868 |
| 4 | CH Ellis | Sussex v Surrey | Royal Brunswick Ground, Hove | 1868 |
| 4 | S Biddulph | Nottinghamshire v Surrey | Kennington Oval, Kennington | 1869 |
| 4 | M Turner | Gentlemen of England v Oxford University | Magdalen Ground, Oxford | 1870 |
| 4 | G Pinder | Yorkshire v Lancashire | Bramall Lane, Sheffield | 1872 |
| 4 | G Pinder | Yorkshire v Nottinghamshire | Trent Bridge, Nottingham | 1875 |
| 4 | R Pilling | Lancashire v Yorkshire | Old Trafford, Manchester | 1878 |
| 4 | KD Borrowes | Middlesex v Yorkshire | Lord's Cricket Ground, St John's Wood | 1882 |
| 4 | AH Jarvis | Australian XI v Victoria | Melbourne Cricket Ground, Melbourne | 1885/86 |
| 4 | H Philipson | Oxford University v Lancashire | Aigburth, Liverpool | 1887 |
| 4 | M Sherwin | Nottinghamshire v Yorkshire | Bramall Lane, Sheffield | 1887 |
| 4 | JM Blackham | Australians v South | Kennington Oval, Kennington | 1890 |
| 4 | WH Brain | Gloucestershire v Somerset | College Ground, Cheltenham | 1893 |
| 4 | D Hunter | Yorkshire v Gloucestershire | Park Avenue Cricket Ground, Bradford | 1895 |
| 4 | L Radcliffe | Lancashire v Middlesex | Old Trafford, Manchester | 1898 |
| 4 | JP Whiteside | Leicestershire v Essex | Aylestone Road, Leicester | 1901 |
| 4 | TM Russell | Essex v Kent | St Lawrence Ground, Canterbury | 1901 |
| 4 | RA Bennett | RA Bennett's XI v Jamaica | Sabina Park, Kingston | 1901/02 |
| 4 | G Gaukrodger | Worcestershire v Somerset | County Ground, Taunton | 1902 |
| 4 | J Humphries | Marylebone Cricket Club v South Africans | Lord's Cricket Ground, St John's Wood | 1904 |
| 4 | WL Nelson | Jamaica v Lord Brackley's XI | Sabina Park, Kingston | 1904/05 |
| 4 | EW Bale | Worcestershire v Australians | County Ground, New Road, Worcester | 1909 |
| 4 | EW Bale | Worcestershire v Surrey | War Memorial Ground, Amblecote | 1910 |
| 4 | FH Huish | Kent v Northamptonshire | County Ground, Northampton | 1911 |
| 4 | FH Huish | Kent v Surrey | Kennington Oval, Kennington | 1911 |
| 4 | EW Bale | Worcestershire v South Africans | County Ground, New Road, Worcester | 1912 |
| 4 | FH Huish | Kent v Leicestershire | Crabble Athletic Ground, Dover | 1912 |
| 4 | FH Huish | Kent v Northamptonshire | St Lawrence Ground, Canterbury | 1914 |
| 4 | EJ Long | Australian Imperial Forces v Somerset | County Ground, Taunton | 1919 |
| 4 | DC Robinson | Army v Royal Navy | Lord's Cricket Ground, St John's Wood | 1921 |
| 4 | RA Boddington | Lancashire v Essex | County Ground, Leyton | 1921 |
| 4 | WR Allen | Yorkshire v Sussex | County Ground, Hove | 1921 |
| 4 | JC Hubble | Kent v Somerset | County Ground, Taunton | 1922 |
| 4 | H Smith | Gloucestershire v Sussex | Greenbank, Bristol | 1923 |
| 4 | TW Oates | Nottinghamshire v Leicestershire | Trent Bridge, Nottingham | 1923 |
| 4 | A Dolphin | Yorkshire v Surrey | Kennington Oval, Kennington | 1924 |
| 4 | WAS Oldfield | Australia v England | Melbourne Cricket Ground, Melbourne | 1924/25 |
| 4 | JC Hubble | Kent v Gloucestershire | Bat and Ball Ground, Gravesend | 1926 |
| 4 | H Elliott | Derbyshire v Warwickshire | Edgbaston, Birmingham | 1926 |
| 4 | LEG Ames | Kent v Derbyshire | Mote Park, Maidstone | 1928 |
| 4 | FW Gilligan | Essex v Gloucestershire | College Ground, Cheltenham | 1928 |
| 4 | G Duckworth | Lancashire v Northamptonshire | Old Trafford, Manchester | 1930 |
| 4 | LEG Ames | Kent v Warwickshire | Angel Ground, Tonbridge | 1930 |
| 4 | LEG Ames | Kent v Glamorgan | St Lawrence Ground, Canterbury | 1932 |
| 4 | PC Oldfield | Oxford University v Marylebone Cricket Club | Lord's Cricket Ground, St John's Wood | 1933 |
| 4 | H Elliott | Derbyshire v Sussex | The Park, Buxton | 1934 |
| 4 | RJ Williams | Natal v Griqualand West | Kingsmead, Durban | 1934/35 |
| 4 | WHV Levett | Kent v Glamorgan | The Nevill Ground, Tunbridge Wells | 1935 |
| 4 | CKQ Jackman | Canterbury v Wellington | Basin Reserve, Wellington | 1935/36 |
| 4 | SVT Chari | Indians v Europeans | Madras Cricket Club Ground, Chepauk, Madras | 1935/36 |
| 4 | G Duckworth | Lancashire v Warwickshire | Old Trafford, Manchester | 1936 |
| 4 | EWT Tindill | New Zealanders v Glamorgan | Cardiff Arms Park, Cardiff | 1937 |
| 4 | J Buckingham | Warwickshire v Surrey | Kennington Oval, Kennington | 1938 |
| 4 | D Tallon | Queensland v Victoria | Brisbane Cricket Ground, Woolloongabba, Brisbane | 1938/39 |
| 4 | CW Walker | South Australia v New South Wales | Sydney Cricket Ground, Sydney | 1939/40 |
| 4 | TM Doraiswami | Madras v Hyderabad | Madras Cricket Club Ground, Chepauk, Madras | 1940/41 |
| 4 | LAW Kent | Auckland v Wellington | Basin Reserve, Wellington | 1944/45 |
| 4 | RJ Williams | Natal v Transvaal | Old Wanderers, Johannesburg | 1945/46 |
| 4 | WT Luckes | Somerset v Middlesex | County Ground, Taunton | 1946 |
| 4 | TH Wade | Essex v Middlesex | Castle Park Cricket Ground, Colchester | 1947 |
| 4 | WW Wade | Natal v Griqualand West | Kingsmead, Durban | 1947/48 |
| 4 | Nisar Ahmed | Punjab Governor's XI v Punjab University, Lahore | Bagh-e-Jinnah, Lahore | 1947/48 |
| 4 | AS Mills | Otago v Fiji | Carisbrook, Dunedin | 1947/48 |
| 4 | RA Saggers | Australians v Surrey | Kennington Oval, Kennington | 1948 |
| 4 | PS Loeser | Transvaal v Natal | Ellis Park, Johannesburg | 1948/49 |
| 4 | H Yarnold | Worcestershire v Somerset | Chester Road North, Kidderminster | 1949 |
| 4 | H Yarnold | Worcestershire v Cambridge University | County Ground, New Road, Worcester | 1950 |
| 4 | CRN Maxwell | Worcestershire v Cambridge University | County Ground, New Road, Worcester | 1951 |
| 4 | PK Sen | India v England | Madras Cricket Club Ground, Chepauk, Madras | 1951/52 |
| 4 | PA Gibb | Essex v Middlesex | Chalkwell Park, Westcliff-on-Sea | 1953 |
| 4 | EJ Rowe | Nottinghamshire v Somerset | Trent Bridge, Nottingham | 1955 |
| 4 | HW Stephenson | Somerset v Lancashire | Old Trafford, Manchester | 1955 |
| 4 | BA Barnett | Commonwealth XI v England XI | The Recreation Ground, Torquay | 1955 |
| 4 | ATW Grout | Queensland v Western Australia | Brisbane Cricket Ground, Woolloongabba, Brisbane | 1956/57 |
| 4 | PK Sen | Past XI v Present XI | Feroz Shah Kotla, Delhi | 1957/58 |
| 4 | TG Evans | South v North | Stanley Park, Blackpool | 1961 |
| 4 | DA Ford | New South Wales v Victoria | Sydney Cricket Ground, Sydney | 1963/64 |
| 4 | RA Jeejeebhoy | Bengal v Assam | Eden Gardens, Calcutta | 1971/72 |
| 4 | JT Murray | Middlesex v Sussex | County Ground, Hove | 1973 |
| 4 | Arifuddin | United Bank Limited v Karachi Whites | National Stadium, Karachi | 1975/76 |
| 4 | R Raina | Jammu and Kashmir v Punjab | Amar Singh Club Ground, Srinagar | 1978/79 |
| 4 | TR Madsen | Natal B v Griqualand West | De Beers Country Club, Kimberley | 1981/82 |
| 4 | Zulqarnain | Railways v National Bank of Pakistan | Niaz Stadium, Hyderabad | 1982/83 |
| 4 | Zulqarnain | Railways v Rawalpindi | Combined Military Transport and Stores Depot Ground, Rawalpindi | 1982/83 |
| 4 | Masood Iqbal | Habib Bank Limited v Lahore City | Punjab University Old Campus Ground, Lahore | 1982/83 |
| 4 | Khalid Jamal | Multan v Lahore City Greens | Gaddafi Stadium, Lahore | 1983/84 |
| 4 | Shahid Munir | Rawalpindi v Dera Ismail Khan | Peshawar Club Ground, Peshawar | 1983/84 |
| 4 | Arifuddin | United Bank Limited v Pakistan Automobiles Corporation | Zafar Ali Stadium, Sahiwal | 1983/84 |
| 4 | T Gard | Somerset v Nottinghamshire | County Ground, Taunton | 1984 |
| 4 | EB McSweeney | Wellington v Northern Districts | Basin Reserve, Wellington | 1984/85 |
| 4 | Anil Dalpat | Karachi Whites v Sukkur | National Stadium, Karachi | 1985/86 |
| 4 | Anil Dalpat | Karachi Whites v Quetta | National Stadium, Karachi | 1985/86 |
| 4 | Bilal Ahmed | Faisalabad v Sargodha | Sports Stadium, Sargodha | 1985/86 |
| 4 | Salim Ahmed | Haryana v Services | Palam A Ground, Model Sports Complex, Delhi | 1986/87 |
| 4 | NH Phadnis | Maharashtra v Tamil Nadu | MA Chidambaram Stadium, Chepauk, Madras | 1988/89 |
| 4 | Haider Nisar | Pakistan International Airlines v Agriculture Development Bank of Pakistan | Pindi Club Ground, Rawalpindi | 1989/90 |
| 4 | ND Burns | Somerset v Worcestershire | Clarence Park, Weston-super-Mare | 1991 |
| 4 | KR Brown | Middlesex v Surrey | The Foster's Oval, Kennington | 1992 |
| 4 | A Sharma | Railways v Madhya Pradesh | Palam A Ground, Model Sports Complex, Delhi | 1992/93 |
| 4 | MY Kudagodage | Police Sports Club v Galle Cricket Club | Police Park Ground, Colombo | 1995/96 |
| 4 | GST Perera | Bloomfield Cricket and Athletic Club v Antonians Sports Club | Bloomfield Cricket and Athletic Club Ground, Colombo | 1996/97 |
| 4 | Humayun Farhat | Lahore Blues v Lahore Whites | Lahore City Cricket Association Ground, Lahore | 2001/02 |
| 4 | TR Rasanga | Sri Lanka Navy Sports Club v Kurunegala Youth Cricket Club | Navy Ground, Welisara | 2011/12 |
| 4 | NLSDN Lokubandara | Negombo Cricket Club v Kalutara Town Club | Kadirana Cricket Grounds, Gampaha | 2017/18 |
| 4 | A Bains | Himachal Pradesh v Madhya Pradesh | Holkar Stadium, Indore | 2018/19 |
| 4 | ALKL Abeyrathne | Bloomfield Cricket and Athletic Club v Kurunegala Youth Cricket Club | Bloomfield Cricket and Athletic Club Ground, Colombo | 2018/19 |
