| 81 | WG Grace | Gloucestershire v Nottinghamshire (1) | Trent Bridge, Nottingham | 1885 |
| 81 | JT Rawlin | GF Vernon's XI v South Australia (2) | Adelaide Oval, Adelaide | 1887/88 |
| 74 | A Shaw | North v South (1) | Trent Bridge, Nottingham | 1876 |
| 72 | A Watson | Lancashire v Marylebone Cricket Club (1) | Lord's Cricket Ground, St John's Wood | 1884 |
| 71 | WA Woof | Gloucestershire v Nottinghamshire (1) | Trent Bridge, Nottingham | 1885 |
| 71 | A Watson | Lancashire v Yorkshire (1) | Park Avenue Cricket Ground, Bradford | 1887 |
| 69 | E Peate | Yorkshire v Sussex (1) | County Ground, Hove | 1884 |
| 68 | G Burton | Middlesex v Nottinghamshire (1) | Lord's Cricket Ground, St John's Wood | 1885 |
| 67 | A Watson | Lancashire v Nottinghamshire (1) | Trent Bridge, Nottingham | 1887 |
| 66 | S Cosstick | Victoria v New South Wales (2) | Albert Cricket Ground, Sydney | 1874/75 |
| 66 | A Shaw | North v South (1) | Trent Bridge, Nottingham | 1878 |
| 66 | W Flowers | Nottinghamshire v Lancashire (1) | Old Trafford, Manchester | 1886 |
| 65 | W Attewell | Nottinghamshire v Kent (2) | Mote Park, Maidstone | 1888 |
| 64 | WA Woof | Gloucestershire v Yorkshire (1) | Clifton College Close Ground, Clifton | 1888 |
| 63 | J Southerton | Surrey v Sussex (1) | County Ground, Hove | 1875 |
| 63 | TW Garrett | New South Wales v Victoria (1) | Melbourne Cricket Ground, Melbourne | 1883/84 |
| 62 | W Attewell | Nottinghamshire v Kent (1) | Trent Bridge, Nottingham | 1888 |
| 59 | A Shaw | Nottinghamshire v Middlesex (1) | Trent Bridge, Nottingham | 1874 |
| 59 | A Shaw | Nottinghamshire v Lancashire (1) | Trent Bridge, Nottingham | 1877 |
| 59 | A Shaw | England v Kent (1) | St Lawrence Ground, Canterbury | 1878 |
| 58 | J Southerton | Surrey v Nottinghamshire (1) | Kennington Oval, Kennington | 1875 |
| 58 | E Evans | New South Wales v A Shaw's XI (1) | Association Ground, Sydney | 1881/82 |
| 58 | W Attewell | GF Vernon's XI v South Australia (2) | Adelaide Oval, Adelaide | 1887/88 |
| 57 | F Morley | United North of England Eleven v All England Eleven (1) | Back o' the Bank, Bolton | 1871 |
| 57 | F Morley | Nottinghamshire v Gloucestershire (1) | College Ground, Cheltenham | 1877 |
| 57 | J Bray | Kent v Surrey (1) | Kennington Oval, Kennington | 1879 |
| 57 | A Shaw | England v Kent (1) | St Lawrence Ground, Canterbury | 1880 |
| 57 | GG Jones | Surrey v Nottinghamshire (1) | Kennington Oval, Kennington | 1882 |
| 57 | A Watson | Lancashire v Surrey (1) | Old Trafford, Manchester | 1887 |
| 57 | F Martin | Kent v Yorkshire (1) | St Lawrence Ground, Canterbury | 1887 |
| 57 | CTB Turner | Australian XI v New South Wales (1) | Association Ground, Sydney | 1888/89 |
| 56 | A Shaw | Marylebone Cricket Club v Oxford University (1) | Magdalen Ground, Oxford | 1878 |
| 56 | A Shaw | Marylebone Cricket Club v Cambridge University (1) | Lord's Cricket Ground, St John's Wood | 1880 |
| 56 | R Peel | England v Australia (1) | Melbourne Cricket Ground, Melbourne | 1884/85 |
| 55 | J Lillywhite | Sussex v Surrey (1) | Royal Brunswick Ground, Hove | 1865 |
| 55 | T Hearne | Middlesex v Nottinghamshire (2) | Cattle Market Ground, Islington | 1866 |
| 55 | A Watson | Lancashire v Kent (2) | Old Trafford, Manchester | 1886 |
| 55 | TW Garrett | Australia v England (1) | Kennington Oval, Kennington | 1886 |
| 54 | J Lillywhite | Sussex v Kent (1) | Bat and Ball Ground, Gravesend | 1866 |
| 54 | RG Barlow | Lancashire v Kent (2) | Old Trafford, Manchester | 1885 |
| 54 | T Emmett | Marylebone Cricket Club v Kent (1) | St Lawrence Ground, Canterbury | 1885 |
| 54 | W Attewell | Nottinghamshire v Yorkshire (1) | Bramall Lane, Sheffield | 1887 |
| 53 | J Lillywhite | Sussex v Surrey (1) | Royal Brunswick Ground, Hove | 1866 |
| 53 | A Shaw | North v South (1) | Prince's Cricket Ground, Chelsea | 1878 |
| 53 | J Potter | Surrey v Kent (1) | Kennington Oval, Kennington | 1880 |
| 53 | CT Studd | Cambridge University v England XI (1) | FP Fenner's Ground, Cambridge | 1882 |
| 53 | W Attewell | Nottinghamshire v Kent (1) | Trent Bridge, Nottingham | 1886 |
| 52 | A Shaw | Players v Australians (1) | Prince's Cricket Ground, Chelsea | 1878 |
| 52 | A Shaw | Nottinghamshire v Yorkshire (1) | Bramall Lane, Sheffield | 1879 |
| 52 | WE Midwinter | Gloucestershire v Surrey (1) | College Ground, Cheltenham | 1880 |
| 52 | GA Lohmann | Surrey v Nottinghamshire (1) | Kennington Oval, Kennington | 1886 |
| 52 | W Flowers | Nottinghamshire v Surrey (1) | Trent Bridge, Nottingham | 1888 |
| 52 | W Flowers | Nottinghamshire v Lancashire (1) | Old Trafford, Manchester | 1888 |
| 51 | E Willsher | Kent v Nottinghamshire (1) | Trent Bridge, Nottingham | 1870 |
| 51 | A Shaw | Marylebone Cricket Club v Oxford University (1) | Magdalen Ground, Oxford | 1875 |
| 51 | J Southerton | Surrey v Middlesex (2) | Kennington Oval, Kennington | 1877 |
| 51 | J Lillywhite | Sussex v Kent (1) | County Ground, Hove | 1880 |
| 51 | A Watson | Lancashire v Yorkshire (1) | Fartown, Huddersfield | 1885 |
| 51 | G Giffen | Australians v Players (1) | Trent Bridge, Nottingham | 1886 |
| 51 | A Shaw | Nottinghamshire v Lancashire (1) | Old Trafford, Manchester | 1886 |
| 50 | A Shaw | Players v Gentlemen (1) | Kennington Oval, Kennington | 1871 |
| 50 | A Shaw | Nottinghamshire v Surrey (2) | Kennington Oval, Kennington | 1876 |
| 50 | D Buchanan | Gentlemen of England v Cambridge University (1) | FP Fenner's Ground, Cambridge | 1877 |
| 50 | A Shaw | Marylebone Cricket Club v Cambridge University (1) | FP Fenner's Ground, Cambridge | 1878 |
| 50 | D Buchanan | Gentlemen of England v Cambridge University (1) | FP Fenner's Ground, Cambridge | 1880 |
| 50 | A Shaw | Nottinghamshire v Lancashire (2) | Aigburth, Liverpool | 1882 |
| 50 | WA Woof | Gloucestershire v Australians (1) | Clifton College Close Ground, Clifton | 1884 |
| 50 | J Briggs | Lancashire v Yorkshire (1) | Park Avenue Cricket Ground, Bradford | 1887 |
| 50 | A Watson | Lancashire v Yorkshire (1) | Old Trafford, Manchester | 1887 |
