| 7 | FW Lillywhite | Hampshire and Surrey v Sussex | Bramshill Park, Bramshill | 1826 |
| 7 | JH Bruce-Lockhart | Yorkshire v Cambridge University | FP Fenner's Ground, Cambridge | 1909 |
| 7 | AP Freeman | Warwickshire v Kent | Angel Ground, Tonbridge | 1930 |
| 7 | VI Smith | Griqualand West v Natal | Kingsmead, Durban | 1947/48 |
| 6 | AG Steel | Nottinghamshire v Lancashire | Old Trafford, Manchester | 1878 |
| 6 | ED Barratt | Kent v Surrey | Kennington Oval, Kennington | 1878 |
| 6 | WE Merritt | Wellington v Canterbury | Basin Reserve, Wellington | 1935/36 |
| 6 | Amir Elahi | The Rest v Muslims | Brabourne Stadium, Bombay | 1940/41 |
| 6 | C Burke | Wellington v Auckland | Basin Reserve, Wellington | 1944/45 |
| 5 | J Southerton | Surrey v Hampshire | Day's (Antelope) Ground, Southampton | 1865 |
| 5 | FG Pelham | Marylebone Cricket Club v Cambridge University | FP Fenner's Ground, Cambridge | 1867 |
| 5 | J Southerton | Lancashire v Surrey | Kennington Oval, Kennington | 1868 |
| 5 | RF Miles | Surrey v Gloucestershire | Kennington Oval, Kennington | 1870 |
| 5 | WG Grace | England v Kent and Gloucestershire | St Lawrence Ground, Canterbury | 1875 |
| 5 | A Penn | Hampshire v Kent | Day's (Antelope) Ground, Southampton | 1876 |
| 5 | AH Stratford | Surrey v Middlesex | Kennington Oval, Kennington | 1878 |
| 5 | WA Humphreys | Kent v Sussex | County Ground, Hove | 1884 |
| 5 | GE Palmer | Victoria v Australian XI | Melbourne Cricket Ground, Melbourne | 1885/86 |
| 5 | R Peel | Sussex v Yorkshire | County Ground, Hove | 1889 |
| 5 | EJ Tyler | Sussex v Somerset | County Ground, Taunton | 1895 |
| 5 | W Rhodes | Surrey v Yorkshire | Park Avenue Cricket Ground, Bradford | 1898 |
| 5 | F Geeson | Derbyshire v Leicestershire | North Road, Glossop | 1901 |
| 5 | MM Moyston | Lord Brackley's XI v Jamaica | Sabina Park, Kingston | 1904/05 |
| 5 | EG Dennett | Northamptonshire v Gloucestershire | Ashley Down Ground, Bristol | 1908 |
| 5 | EG Dennett | Northamptonshire v Gloucestershire | Spa Ground, Gloucester | 1909 |
| 5 | EG Dennett | Northamptonshire v Gloucestershire | Ashley Down Ground, Bristol | 1910 |
| 5 | DW Carr | Surrey v Kent | Kennington Oval, Kennington | 1911 |
| 5 | SG Smith | Essex v Northamptonshire | County Ground, Northampton | 1913 |
| 5 | HL Collins | Somerset v Australian Imperial Forces | County Ground, Taunton | 1919 |
| 5 | RHB Bettington | Surrey v Oxford University | Kennington Oval, Kennington | 1920 |
| 5 | AP Freeman | Leicestershire v Kent | Bat and Ball Ground, Gravesend | 1921 |
| 5 | GM Lee | Leicestershire v Derbyshire | County Ground, Derby | 1928 |
| 5 | WE Merritt | Otago v Canterbury | Carisbrook, Dunedin | 1928/29 |
| 5 | CV Grimmett | New South Wales v South Australia | Sydney Cricket Ground, Sydney | 1928/29 |
| 5 | RWV Robins | Warwickshire v Middlesex | Edgbaston, Birmingham | 1929 |
| 5 | AP Freeman | Gloucestershire v Kent | Fry's Ground, Bristol | 1930 |
| 5 | HC Chilvers | West Indians v New South Wales | Sydney Cricket Ground, Sydney | 1930/31 |
| 5 | TB Mitchell | Sussex v Derbyshire | Queen's Park, Chesterfield | 1931 |
| 5 | AP Freeman | Northamptonshire v Kent | The Nevill Ground, Tunbridge Wells | 1932 |
| 5 | CV Grimmett | Queensland v South Australia | Brisbane Cricket Ground, Woolloongabba, Brisbane | 1932/33 |
| 5 | HRW Butterworth | Cambridge University v Minor Counties | FP Fenner's Ground, Cambridge | 1935 |
| 5 | AP Freeman | Glamorgan v Kent | The Nevill Ground, Tunbridge Wells | 1935 |
| 5 | CG Macartney | India v Australians | Madras Cricket Club Ground, Chepauk, Madras | 1935/36 |
| 5 | CV Grimmett | New South Wales v South Australia | Sydney Cricket Ground, Sydney | 1939/40 |
| 5 | Amir Elahi | Nawanagar v Baroda | Ajitsinhji Ground, Jamnagar | 1945/46 |
| 5 | GE Tribe | New South Wales v Victoria | Sydney Cricket Ground, Sydney | 1946/47 |
| 5 | R Howorth | Cambridge University v Worcestershire | County Ground, New Road, Worcester | 1950 |
| 5 | RO Jenkins | Scotland v Worcestershire | Forthill, Dundee | 1951 |
| 5 | MH Mankad | England v India | Madras Cricket Club Ground, Chepauk, Madras | 1951/52 |
| 5 | JE Walsh | Kent v Leicestershire | Cheriton Road Sports Ground, Folkestone | 1952 |
| 5 | JS Manning | England XI v Commonwealth XI | Central Recreation Ground, Hastings | 1960 |
| 5 | DR Doshi | Assam v Bengal | Eden Gardens, Calcutta | 1971/72 |
| 5 | Shahid Aziz | Pakistan Automobiles Corporation v United Bank Limited | Zafar Ali Stadium, Sahiwal | 1983/84 |
| 5 | ND Hirwani | West Indies v India | MA Chidambaram Stadium, Chepauk, Madras | 1987/88 |
| 5 | KJ Silva | Old Cambrians Sports Club v Kalutara Physical Culture Centre | Tyronne Fernando Stadium, Moratuwa | 1991/92 |
| 5 | Mohammad Hussain | Lahore Whites v Lahore Blues | Lahore City Cricket Association Ground, Lahore | 2001/02 |
