| 5 | J Southerton | Surrey (2) v Hampshire | Day's (Antelope) Ground, Southampton | 1865 |
| 5 | J Southerton | Lancashire (1) v Surrey | Kennington Oval, Kennington | 1868 |
| 5 | AG Steel | Nottinghamshire (2) v Lancashire | Old Trafford, Manchester | 1878 |
| 5 | JH Bruce-Lockhart | Yorkshire (2) v Cambridge University | FP Fenner's Ground, Cambridge | 1909 |
| 5 | JS Manning | England XI (2) v Commonwealth XI | Central Recreation Ground, Hastings | 1960 |
| 4 | FW Lillywhite | Hampshire and Surrey (2) v Sussex | Bramshill Park, Bramshill | 1826 |
| 4 | R Iddison | Nottinghamshire (1) v Yorkshire | Great Horton Road, Bradford | 1864 |
| 4 | R Daft | Surrey (2) v Nottinghamshire | Kennington Oval, Kennington | 1869 |
| 4 | D Buchanan | Oxford University (1) v Gentlemen of England | Magdalen Ground, Oxford | 1870 |
| 4 | T Armitage | Nottinghamshire (2) v Yorkshire | Trent Bridge, Nottingham | 1875 |
| 4 | AG Steel | Yorkshire (2) v Lancashire | Old Trafford, Manchester | 1878 |
| 4 | WH Cooper | Lord Harris' XI (1) v Victoria | Melbourne Cricket Ground, Melbourne | 1878/79 |
| 4 | G Burton | Yorkshire (2) v Middlesex | Lord's Cricket Ground, St John's Wood | 1882 |
| 4 | GE Palmer | Victoria (1) v Australian XI | Melbourne Cricket Ground, Melbourne | 1885/86 |
| 4 | F Geeson | Essex (1) v Leicestershire | Aylestone Road, Leicester | 1901 |
| 4 | CP McGahey | Kent (1) v Essex | St Lawrence Ground, Canterbury | 1901 |
| 4 | BJT Bosanquet | Nottinghamshire (2) v Middlesex | Trent Bridge, Nottingham | 1902 |
| 4 | BJT Bosanquet | South Africans (1) v Marylebone Cricket Club | Lord's Cricket Ground, St John's Wood | 1904 |
| 4 | MM Moyston | Lord Brackley's XI (1) v Jamaica | Sabina Park, Kingston | 1904/05 |
| 4 | GHT Simpson-Hayward | Australians (1) v Worcestershire | County Ground, New Road, Worcester | 1909 |
| 4 | GHT Simpson-Hayward | Surrey (2) v Worcestershire | War Memorial Ground, Amblecote | 1910 |
| 4 | DW Carr | Surrey (1) v Kent | Kennington Oval, Kennington | 1911 |
| 4 | GHT Simpson-Hayward | South Africans (1) v Worcestershire | County Ground, New Road, Worcester | 1912 |
| 4 | HL Collins | Somerset (2) v Australian Imperial Forces | County Ground, Taunton | 1919 |
| 4 | TL Richmond | Leicestershire (2) v Nottinghamshire | Trent Bridge, Nottingham | 1923 |
| 4 | GM Lee | Warwickshire (1) v Derbyshire | Edgbaston, Birmingham | 1926 |
| 4 | AP Freeman | Warwickshire (1) v Kent | Angel Ground, Tonbridge | 1930 |
| 4 | AP Freeman | Glamorgan (1) v Kent | St Lawrence Ground, Canterbury | 1932 |
| 4 | HGO Owen-Smith | Marylebone Cricket Club (1) v Oxford University | Lord's Cricket Ground, St John's Wood | 1933 |
| 4 | TB Mitchell | Sussex (1) v Derbyshire | The Park, Buxton | 1934 |
| 4 | AP Freeman | Glamorgan (2) v Kent | The Nevill Ground, Tunbridge Wells | 1935 |
| 4 | T Allen | Marylebone Cricket Club (1) v Queensland | Brisbane Cricket Ground, Woolloongabba, Brisbane | 1935/36 |
| 4 | AG Ram Singh | Europeans (1) v Indians | Madras Cricket Club Ground, Chepauk, Madras | 1935/36 |
| 4 | C Burke | Wellington (1) v Auckland | Basin Reserve, Wellington | 1944/45 |
| 4 | GE Tribe | New South Wales (1) v Victoria | Sydney Cricket Ground, Sydney | 1946/47 |
| 4 | TPB Smith | Middlesex (2) v Essex | Castle Park Cricket Ground, Colchester | 1947 |
| 4 | VI Smith | Griqualand West (1) v Natal | Kingsmead, Durban | 1947/48 |
| 4 | Mohammad Amin | Punjab University, Lahore (1) v Punjab Governor's XI | Bagh-e-Jinnah, Lahore | 1947/48 |
| 4 | LJ Groves | Fiji (1) v Otago | Carisbrook, Dunedin | 1947/48 |
| 4 | RO Jenkins | Somerset (2) v Worcestershire | Chester Road North, Kidderminster | 1949 |
| 4 | R Howorth | Cambridge University (2) v Worcestershire | County Ground, New Road, Worcester | 1950 |
| 4 | RO Jenkins | Scotland (2) v Worcestershire | Forthill, Dundee | 1951 |
| 4 | MH Mankad | England (1) v India | Madras Cricket Club Ground, Chepauk, Madras | 1951/52 |
| 4 | WT Greensmith | Middlesex (2) v Essex | Chalkwell Park, Westcliff-on-Sea | 1953 |
| 4 | JE Childe-Freeman | Western Australia (1) v Queensland | Brisbane Cricket Ground, Woolloongabba, Brisbane | 1956/57 |
| 4 | S Nagaswamy | Orissa (1) v Bihar | Barabati Stadium, Cuttack | 1965/66 |
| 4 | DR Doshi | Assam (1) v Bengal | Eden Gardens, Calcutta | 1971/72 |
| 4 | A Kaul | Punjab (1) v Jammu and Kashmir | Amar Singh Club Ground, Srinagar | 1978/79 |
| 4 | I Ebrahim | Griqualand West (2) v Natal B | De Beers Country Club, Kimberley | 1981/82 |
| 4 | Masood Anwar | Lahore City Greens (1) v Multan | Gaddafi Stadium, Lahore | 1983/84 |
| 4 | Shahid Aziz | Pakistan Automobiles Corporation (2) v United Bank Limited | Zafar Ali Stadium, Sahiwal | 1983/84 |
| 4 | EJ Gray | Northern Districts (2) v Wellington | Basin Reserve, Wellington | 1984/85 |
| 4 | ND Hirwani | West Indies (2) v India | MA Chidambaram Stadium, Chepauk, Madras | 1987/88 |
