| Main FC | Yorkshire (1861) |
| Yorkshire (1864-1874) | |
| Miscellaneous | Dalton (1848-1862) |
| Huddersfield and Dalton (1850-1851) | |
| Players of Yorkshire (1850) | |
| Bradford (1850-1852) | |
| York (1860) | |
| Barnsley (1861) | |
| Yorkshire (1862) | |
| Dewsbury (1863-1865) | |
| Walsall (1863) | |
| Huddersfield (1863-1865) | |
| TW Hornby's North of England XI (1863) | |
| Stockton and Middlesbrough (1863) | |
| Thirsk (1864) | |
| Ossett (1865-1866) | |
| Mirfield (1865) | |
| All England Eleven (1865-1866) | |
| Earlsheaton (1865) | |
| Bishop Auckland and District (1865) | |
| Tadcaster (1866) | |
| Boston Spa (1875) | |
| Veterans of Yorkshire (1876) |