| Other FC | American Born (1881-1883) |
| Gentlemen of Philadelphia (1883-1886) | |
| Philadelphia (1886) | |
| Halifax Cup | Merion (1880-1912) |
| Merion A (1904) | |
| Merion B (1905-1906) | |
| Miscellaneous | Dorian Second XI (1878) |
| Dorian (1878-1879) | |
| Old Haverfordians (1879) | |
| Merion (1879-1906) | |
| Merion Second XI (1880) | |
| Haverford College (1880-1881) | |
| United States of America (1881-1886) | |
| Gentlemen of Philadelphia (1881/82-1888) | |
| All Philadelphia (1882-1885) | |
| S Law's XI (1883) | |
| Philadelphia Zingari (1884) | |
| WE Roller's XI (1886) | |
| Haverford College Past and Present (1891) | |
| Merion Veterans (1894-1910) | |
| Merion Summer XI (1894) | |
| Philadelphia Veterans (1898-1910) | |
| FJ Stokes' XI (1898) | |
| Germantown Summer XI (1904) | |
| Philadelphia Pilgrims (1906-1910) | |
| Merion B (1907-1910) | |
| All Philadelphia Veterans (1909) |