| Other FC | Gentlemen of Philadelphia (1894-1895) |
| AM Wood's XI (1894) | |
| Halifax Cup | Belmont (1888-1907) |
| Miscellaneous | Belmont Juniors (1882-1884) |
| Belmont Third XI (1883) | |
| Belmont Second XI (1884-1891) | |
| Belmont (1884-1907) | |
| Gentlemen of Leisure (1884) | |
| American I Zingari (1884) | |
| Germantown Second XI (1887) | |
| Riverton (1888) | |
| Belmont Summer XI (1891-1901) | |
| Elmwood (1891-1893) | |
| Philadelphia (1891) | |
| AM Wood's XI (1891-1893) | |
| Gentlemen of Philadelphia (1892) | |
| F Yarnall's XI (1893) | |
| Bank Clerks Athletic Association (1893) | |
| TR Reaney's XI (1893) | |
| S Handford's XI (1893) | |
| University of Pennsylvania (1895) | |
| United States of America (1898-1901) | |
| FL Altemus' XI (1899) | |
| Philadelphia Colts (1899) | |
| West Philadelphia Summer XI (1901) | |
| Belmont C (1906) |