| 4 | TR Ambrose | for Warwickshire | Emirates Old Trafford, Manchester | 2014 | tt4357 |
| 4 | SW Poynter | for Durham | Emirates Riverside, Chester-le-Street | 2018 | tt7125 |
| 3 | CMW Read | for Nottinghamshire | Trent Bridge, Nottingham | 2005 | tt184 |
| 3 | DJ Pipe | for Derbyshire | County Ground, Derby | 2006 | tt362 |
| 3 | P Mustard | for Durham | Old Trafford, Manchester | 2006 | tt406 |
| 3 | OB Cox | for Worcestershire | Emirates Old Trafford, Manchester | 2014 | tt4321 |
| 3 | TR Ambrose | for Warwickshire | Edgbaston, Birmingham | 2018 | tt7138 |
| 2 | WM Noon | for Nottinghamshire | Trent Bridge, Nottingham | 2003 | tt12 |
| 2 | LD Sutton | for Derbyshire | Old Trafford, Manchester | 2003 | tt28 |
| 2 | PA Nixon | for Leicestershire | Old Trafford, Manchester | 2004 | tt69 |
| 2 | LD Sutton | for Derbyshire | County Ground, Derby | 2004 | tt81 |
| 2 | I Dawood | for Yorkshire | Headingley, Leeds | 2005 | tt176 |
| 2 | P Mustard | for Durham | Emirates Durham International Cricket Ground, Chester-le-Street | 2010 | tt1730 |
| 2 | PA Nixon | for Leicestershire | Old Trafford, Manchester | 2010 | tt1748 |
| 2 | D Murphy | for Northamptonshire | County Ground, Northampton | 2010 | tt1858 |
| 2 | PA Nixon | for Leicestershire | Old Trafford, Manchester | 2011 | tt2221 |
| 2 | CMW Read | for Nottinghamshire | Trent Bridge, Nottingham | 2011 | tt2279 |
| 2 | BC Brown | for Sussex | The PROBIZ County Ground, Hove | 2011 | tt2364 |
| 2 | T Poynton | for Derbyshire | County Ground, Derby | 2012 | tt2965 |
| 2 | T Poynton | for Derbyshire | Old Trafford, Manchester | 2012 | tt3027 |
| 2 | T Poynton | for Derbyshire | Emirates Old Trafford, Manchester | 2013 | tt3704 |
| 2 | P Mustard | for Durham | Emirates Old Trafford, Manchester | 2014 | tt4465 |
| 2 | MA Wallace | for Glamorgan | Emirates Old Trafford, Manchester | 2014 | tt4482 |
| 2 | TR Ambrose | for Warwickshire | Edgbaston, Birmingham | 2014 | tt4504 |
| 2 | TR Ambrose | for Warwickshire | Emirates Old Trafford, Manchester | 2015 | tt4992 |
| 2 | P Mustard | for Durham | Emirates Old Trafford, Manchester | 2016 | tt5727 |
| 2 | JM Bairstow | for Yorkshire | Emirates Old Trafford, Manchester | 2016 | tt5742 |
| 2 | P Mustard | for Durham | Emirates Riverside, Chester-le-Street | 2016 | tt5846 |
| 2 | L Ronchi | for Leicestershire | Aigburth, Liverpool | 2017 | tt6317 |
| 2 | SW Poynter | for Durham | Emirates Old Trafford, Manchester | 2018 | tt7104 |
| 2 | SW Billings | for Kent | Spitfire Ground, St Lawrence, Canterbury | 2018 | tt7165 |
| 2 | N Pooran | for Yorkshire | Emerald Headingley Cricket Stadium, Leeds | 2019 | tt7991 |
| 2 | OB Cox | for Worcestershire | Blackfinch New Road, Worcester | 2019 | tt8089 |
| 2 | JA Tattersall | for Yorkshire | Emirates Old Trafford, Manchester | 2020 | tt9000 |
| 2 | T Banton | for Somerset | The Cooper Associates County Ground, Taunton | 2021 | tt9937 |
| 2 | GH Roderick | for Worcestershire | County Ground, New Road, Worcester | 2022 | tt11059 |
| 2 | JA Tattersall | for Yorkshire | Headingley, Leeds | 2023 | tt12261 |
| 2 | AL Davies | for Warwickshire | Emirates Old Trafford, Manchester | 2024 | tt13731 |
| 2 | GH Roderick | for Worcestershire | Emirates Old Trafford, Manchester | 2024 | tt13901 |
| 2 | LD McManus | for Northamptonshire | Emirates Old Trafford, Manchester | 2024 | tt13986 |