| 4 | GJ Maxwell | v Nottinghamshire | Emirates Old Trafford, Manchester | 2019 | tt8023 |
| 4 | TH David | v Leicestershire | Uptonsteel County Ground, Leicester | 2022 | tt10921 |
| 3 | KW Hogg | v Derbyshire | County Ground, Derby | 2008 | tt919 |
| 3 | SJ Croft | v Yorkshire | Old Trafford, Manchester | 2009 | tt1228 |
| 3 | SM Katich | v Warwickshire | Old Trafford, Manchester | 2010 | tt1782 |
| 3 | NL McCullum | v Yorkshire | Old Trafford, Manchester | 2010 | tt1839 |
| 3 | SJ Croft | v Leicestershire | Grace Road, Leicester | 2014 | tt4433 |
| 3 | LS Livingstone | v Yorkshire | Headingley, Leeds | 2017 | tt6413 |
| 3 | MRJ Watt | v Yorkshire | Emerald Headingley Cricket Stadium, Leeds | 2018 | tt7113 |
| 3 | SJ Croft | v Yorkshire | Emerald Headingley Cricket Stadium, Leeds | 2018 | tt7113 |
| 3 | JJ Bohannon | v Durham | Emirates Old Trafford, Manchester | 2019 | tt7978 |
| 3 | DJ Vilas | v Leicestershire | Fischer County Ground, Grace Road, Leicester | 2020 | tt8896 |
| 3 | AL Davies | v Northamptonshire | Emirates Old Trafford, Manchester | 2021 | tt9813 |
| 3 | SJ Croft | v Nottinghamshire | Trent Bridge, Nottingham | 2022 | tt10876 |
| 3 | TW Hartley | v Yorkshire | Edgbaston, Birmingham | 2022 | tt11143 |
| 3 | SJ Croft | v Worcestershire | Stanley Park, Blackpool | 2023 | tt12307 |
| 3 | LS Livingstone | v Nottinghamshire | Emirates Old Trafford, Manchester | 2024 | tt13972 |