| Yorkshire Premier League | Cleethorpes (2011-2013) |
| Yorkshire South Premier League | Cleethorpes (2017-2019) |
| Miscellaneous | Cleethorpes Fourth XI (2007-2008) |
| Cleethorpes (2009-2014) | |
| Cleethorpes Third XI (2010) | |
| Cleethorpes Fifth XI (2013) | |
| Cleethorpes Second XI (2015-2024) |