| Cricketer Cup | Old Hurst Johnians (2017-2023) |
| Miscellaneous | DJ Semmence's XI (1985) |
| Sussex Martlets (1988-2009) | |
| Headmasters' Conference Southern Schools (1990-1991) | |
| Old Hurst Johnians (1990-2024) | |
| Sussex Young Cricketers (1991) | |
| Marylebone Cricket Club Schools (1991) | |
| National Association of Young Cricketers (1991) | |
| Marylebone Cricket Club (1992-2015) | |
| Durham University (1993-1995) | |
| Free Foresters (1995-1999) | |
| Earl of Arundel's XI (1996-2002) | |
| Arabs (2003-2004) | |
| Hurlingham Club (2003-2006) | |
| Duke of Norfolk's XI (2003) | |
| CDA Martin-Jenkins' XI (2005) | |
| I Zingari (2009-2014) |