| Miscellaneous | Boston Cricket Club (1879) |
| Longwood (1881-1899) | |
| Boston (1881-1904) | |
| Boston Zingari (1884) | |
| New England (1885-1886) | |
| Manhattan Wanderers (1885) | |
| Married of Longwood Club (1889) | |
| Boston Athletic Association (1889-1899) | |
| JW Dutton's XI (1889) | |
| Newport (1889-1904) | |
| All Boston (1892) | |
| Massachusetts (1893-1894) | |
| Boston Athletic Association Juniors (1896) | |
| W Pettitt's XI (1896) | |
| W Haigh's XI (1897) | |
| JL Chambers' XI (1900) | |
| Roxbury (1903) | |
| T Pettitt's XI (1903-1931) | |
| Highlandville (1907) | |
| J Goddard's XI (1907) |