| Miscellaneous | Longwood (1878-1899) |
| Married of Longwood Club (1883-1889) | |
| Brewster's XI (1884) | |
| Boston Zingari (1884) | |
| United States of America (1884) | |
| CL Bixby's XI (1884-1894) | |
| New England (1885-1886) | |
| JW Dutton's XI (1886) | |
| Brown's XI (1887) | |
| Foxborough (1887) | |
| Gentlemen of United States of America (1887/88) | |
| Boston Athletic Association (1889-1899) | |
| Massachusetts (1889-1893) | |
| AJ Mercer's XI (1891) | |
| Boston (1892) | |
| Boston Athletic Association Second XI (1894) | |
| W Howarth's XI (1894) | |
| Boston Athletic Association Summer XI (1896) | |
| JB Thorpe's XI (1898) | |
| JL Chambers' XI (1900) |