| Halifax Cup | New York and Metropolitan District Cricket League (1915) |
| Staten Island Cricket Club (1916) | |
| Westchester-Biltmore (1924) | |
| Miscellaneous | Brooklyn (1890-1910) |
| Brooklyn Second XI (1890) | |
| All Brooklyn (1891) | |
| New York and District (1893) | |
| Manhattan (1894) | |
| West Indian (1900) | |
| Schenectady (1903-1913) | |
| All New York (1903-1918) | |
| Brooklyn A (1904-1906) | |
| Brooklyn Zingari (1905) | |
| New York and Metropolitan District Cricket League (1905) | |
| HA Laurie's XI (1906) | |
| Zingari (1908) | |
| New York Veterans (1910-1925) | |
| Richmond County (1914-1916) | |
| General Electric Company of Schenectady (1915-1917) | |
| Staten Island Cricket Club (1917-1929) | |
| Staten Island Cricket Club Veterans (1917) | |
| Staten Island Cricket Club 1919 (1920) | |
| Crescent Athletic Club (1925-1929) |