| Halifax Cup | Staten Island Cricket Club (1916) |
| Miscellaneous | Metropolitan Club of New York (1887) |
| Manhattan Second XI (1887-1889) | |
| Manhattan (1887-1891) | |
| All New York (1889-1916) | |
| New York East (1890) | |
| New York and Metropolitan District Cricket League (1890-1905) | |
| Berkeley Athletic Club (1890-1892) | |
| WF Keenan's XI (1891) | |
| Chicago (1891) | |
| Staten Island Athletic Club (1892) | |
| New Jersey Athletic Club (1893-1898) | |
| Staten Island Cricket Club (1893-1916) | |
| New York and District (1893) | |
| Bergen Point (1894) | |
| Staten Island and New Jersey Athletic Clubs (1894) | |
| New Jersey (1896) | |
| New Jersey Athletic Club A (1898) | |
| Knickerbocker Athletic Club A (1899) | |
| Knickerbocker Athletic Club (1899-1901) | |
| Livingston Field Club (1900-1902) | |
| Livingston (1902) | |
| New Jersey Club (1903) | |
| Staten Island Cricket Club A (1905) | |
| New York and New Jersey Cricket Association (1910-1916) |