Teams Paul McMahon played for

Main FCNottinghamshire (2002-2006)
 Oxford University (2003-2005)
Main ListANottinghamshire (2003-2006)
Main Twenty20Nottinghamshire (2005)
Other FCOxford University Centre of Cricketing Excellence (2003-2008)
 British Universities (2004)
Under-19 TestEngland Under-19s (2002)
Under-19 ODIEngland Under-19s (2001/02-2002)
Minor Counties ChampionshipOxfordshire (2007-2009)
 Cambridgeshire (2010-2018)
Minor Counties TrophyNottinghamshire Cricket Board (2001-2002)
 Oxfordshire (2007-2009)
 Cambridgeshire (2010-2015)
Minor Counties Twenty20Cambridgeshire (2015)
Second Eleven ChampionshipNottinghamshire Second XI (2001-2006)
 Warwickshire Second XI (2008)
Second Eleven TrophyNottinghamshire Second XI (2001-2006)
 Minor Counties Under-25s (2007-2008)
 Minor Counties (2009)
North Staffordshire and South Cheshire Premier LeagueModdershall (2010)
Northamptonshire Premier LeaguePeterborough Town (2011-2017)
Nottinghamshire Premier LeagueWollaton (1999-2024)
Victoria Premier CricketMelbourne University (2006/07)
Under-17 County ChampionshipNottinghamshire Under-17s (2000)
Under-19 World CupEngland Under-19s (2001/02)
Twenty20 BlastNottinghamshire (2005)
County ChampionshipNottinghamshire (2002-2004)
MiscellaneousNottinghamshire Premier Cricket League (2000-2008)
 Nottinghamshire Under-19s (2001)
 Development of Excellence North XI (2001)
 Nottinghamshire (2002-2005)
 England Under-19s (2002)
 Oxford University (2003-2011)
 Oxford University Centre of Cricketing Excellence (2003-2008)
 Wollaton (2004-2024)
 Sir JP Getty's XI (2004-2012)
 P Johnson's XI (2004)
 Sydney University (2005/06-2015)
 Nottinghamshire Second XI (2006)
 Minor Counties Under-25s (2007)
 Minor Counties (2007-2009)
 Marylebone Cricket Club Universities (2008)
 Harlequins (2010-2015)
 Cambridgeshire (2011-2015)
 Peterborough Town (2011-2014)
 Unicorns (2014)