| Main FC | Nottinghamshire (1858) |
| Miscellaneous | Cambridge University (1857-1858) |
| Grantham (1857-1858) | |
| All England Eleven (1857) | |
| Irnham Park (1857) | |
| Cambridge University Next XXII (1858) | |
| Trinity College, Cambridge (1858) | |
| Players Engaged at Cambridge University (1858) | |
| Eastwell (1858) | |
| United England Eleven (1858) | |
| AW McDougall's Team (1858) | |
| Southgate (1860) | |
| Canada West (1863) | |
| All-Comers (1863) | |
| Civilians (1863) |