| Main FC | Cambridge University (1855-1857) |
| Cambridgeshire (1857) | |
| Other FC | Cambridge Town Club (1857) |
| Miscellaneous | King Edward's School, Birmingham (1851-1854) |
| Birmingham (1854) | |
| Rest of King Edward's School, Birmingham (1854) | |
| Trinity College, Cambridge Second XI (1855) | |
| T Burgoyne's XI (1855) | |
| Trinity College, Cambridge (1855) | |
| Cambridge University (1855-1857) | |
| King Edward's School, Birmingham Past and Present (1855-1858) | |
| Cambridge University Next XIV (1856) | |
| Gentlemen of Cambridgeshire (1856-1859) | |
| A Scratch XI (1856) | |
| Royston (1857) | |
| Old Edwardians (1864) | |
| Handsworth (1867-1869) | |
| Incogniti (1871) | |
| Gentlemen of Staffordshire (1871-1872) | |
| Staffordshire (1872-1873) | |
| Clergy (1873-1885) | |
| Gentlemen of Worcestershire (1873) | |
| Worcestershire (1873) | |
| Blackheath (1886) |