| Main FC | Oxford University (1852-1854) |
| Other FC | Gentlemen of England (1852-1856) |
| Marylebone Cricket Club (1856) | |
| Gentlemen of Marylebone Cricket Club (1860-1862) | |
| Miscellaneous | Stoneleigh (1847-1849) |
| Leamington (1848-1849) | |
| Harrow School (1849-1851) | |
| Gentlemen of Warwickshire (1849-1851) | |
| Oxford University (1852-1856) | |
| Harlequins (1852-1862) | |
| I Zingari (1852-1875) | |
| Oxfordshire (1853-1857) | |
| Oriel College, Oxford (1853-1855) | |
| Old Harrovians (1853-1854) | |
| Marylebone Cricket Club (1854-1861) | |
| Birmingham (1855) | |
| United England Eleven (1855-1860) | |
| Gentlemen of Berkshire (1856-1859) | |
| Gentlemen of England (1856) | |
| United Ireland Eleven (1856) | |
| Quidnuncs (1858) | |
| Peripatetics (1859) | |
| Leicestershire (1860) | |
| Bar (1861) | |
| Old Harrovian Captains (1866) |