| Main FC | Cambridge University (1853-1855) |
| Miscellaneous | Gentlemen of Leicestershire (1853) |
| Cambridge University Second XI (1854) | |
| Cambridge University (1854-1855) | |
| Emmanuel College, Cambridge (1855) | |
| Quidnuncs (1855) | |
| Midland Counties Diamonds (1862) | |
| Gentlemen of Nottinghamshire (1867-1870) |