| Main FC | Yorkshire (1849-1855) |
| Other FC | England (1847-1857) |
| Sheffield (1848-1854) | |
| North (1851-1857) | |
| All England Eleven (1851-1852) | |
| United England Eleven (1853-1857) | |
| Players (1856) | |
| Manchester (1857-1858) | |
| Miscellaneous | Sheffield (1846-1860) |
| Gentlemen of Sheffield (1848) | |
| Carlisle (1850) | |
| All England Eleven (1850-1858) | |
| Players of Yorkshire (1850) | |
| Langton Wold (1850) | |
| Northumberland Club (1851-1852) | |
| Yorkshire (1851) | |
| Preston (1852) | |
| Gentlemen of Yorkshire (1852) | |
| Beverley (1852) | |
| United England Eleven (1852-1857) | |
| Broughton (1855-1873) | |
| T Lockyer's XI (1859) | |
| Radcliffe-on-Trent (1869) |