| Main FC | Yorkshire (1863-1870) |
| Cambridge University (1864-1866) | |
| Other FC | North (1870) |
| Miscellaneous | Westminster School (1858-1862) |
| Morley (1862-1863) | |
| South Yorkshire (1862) | |
| All England Eleven (1862-1864) | |
| Bradford (1862-1865) | |
| Batley (1862) | |
| Harrogate (1862-1863) | |
| Leeds (1862-1863) | |
| Cambridge University Next XVIII (1863) | |
| Gomersal (1863) | |
| Halifax (1863-1864) | |
| Dewsbury (1863-1865) | |
| Otley (1863) | |
| Scarborough (1863) | |
| Cambridge University (1864-1865) | |
| Free Foresters (1864-1865) | |
| Gentlemen of Yorkshire (1864-1865) | |
| Wakefield (1864) | |
| Gentlemen of Halifax (1868) | |
| A Walker's XI (1869) | |
| Surrey County School (1870) | |
| Surrey County School Masters and Friends (1870) | |
| Gentlemen of Staffordshire (1872) | |
| Staffordshire (1872) | |
| South Wales Cricket Club (1875-1876) | |
| Gentlemen of West Glamorgan (1875) | |
| Swansea (1876) | |
| Harrow Town (1879) | |
| Europeans (1882/83-1886/87) | |
| Ceylon (1884) |