Main FC | Yorkshire (1861-1862) |
| Yorkshire (1863-1873) |
Other FC | Sheffield (1854) |
| North (1857-1869) |
| Marylebone Cricket Club (1857-1858) |
| England (1857-1861) |
| All England Eleven (1858-1866) |
| Married (1858) |
| Yorkshire and Durham (1858) |
| United England Eleven (1860-1861) |
| The World (1861/62) |
| Cambridgeshire and Yorkshire (1864) |
Miscellaneous | Sheffield (1851-1864) |
| St Helens (1854) |
| South Wilts (1855) |
| South Wales (1856) |
| Cirencester (1856) |
| Trowbridge (1856) |
| United England Eleven (1856-1866) |
| Bristol (1856) |
| All England Eleven (1856-1867) |
| Llanelly (1856) |
| F Marshall's XI (1857) |
| Marylebone Cricket Club (1857-1858) |
| Earl of Winterton's XI (1858) |
| Irnham Park (1858) |
| Hallam and Staveley (1858-1861) |
| Hallam (1860-1861) |
| Lincolnshire (1860) |
| West Bromwich (1860) |
| HE Handley's Team (1861) |
| Another England Eleven (1861) |
| HH Stephenson's XI (1861/62) |
| E Stephenson's XI (1861/62) |
| South Yorkshire (1862) |
| Yorkshire Colts (1862) |
| Sheffield Collegiate (1862) |
| Scarborough (1862) |
| Halifax (1863) |
| Dewsbury (1863) |
| Otley (1863) |
| Lawton Hall (1863) |
| English Eleven (1864) |
| New All England Eleven (1864) |
| Todmorden (1864-1868) |
| Heckmondwike (1868) |
| Whitehaven (1868) |
| Hunslet (1868) |
| Malton (1869-1875) |
| Worksop (1869) |
| Chesterfield (1869) |
| Rotherham (1870) |
| Ilkley (1870) |
| Sheffield Shrewsbury Club (1870) |
| Barnsley (1871) |
| Grantham (1871) |
| Players of the North (1871) |
| Carlisle (1871) |
| South Oxfordshire (1873) |
| United North of England Eleven (1873) |