| Main FC | Yorkshire (1864) |
| Middlesex (1870) | |
| Other FC | Gentlemen of the North (1861) |
| Southgate (1864) | |
| Miscellaneous | Wimbledon (1859-1863) |
| Sheffield Shrewsbury Club (1861-1862) | |
| South Yorkshire (1862) | |
| Reigate Priory (1863) | |
| Ealing (1863) | |
| United England Eleven (1863) | |
| Incogniti (1863) | |
| Hull (1863) | |
| York (1863) | |
| English Eleven (1864) | |
| Yorkshire Gentlemen (1864) | |
| Sheffield (1864) | |
| Richmond (1864-1874) | |
| Southgate (1864) | |
| Gentlemen of Yorkshire (1864-1868) | |
| Scarborough (1864) | |
| Richmond (1867) | |
| Will-o'-the-Wisp (1870) | |
| I Zingari (1870) |