| Main FC | Cambridgeshire (1868) |
| Miscellaneous | FG Pelham's XI (1867) |
| Cambridge University Freshmen (1867) | |
| Gentlemen of Cambridgeshire (1867) | |
| Bishop's Stortford (1867-1868) | |
| Cambridgeshire (1867) | |
| Cambridge University Long Vacation Club (1868) | |
| Cambridge Town Club and Cambridge University Long Vacation Club (1871) | |
| Gentlemen of Staffordshire (1873) | |
| Northumberland Colts (1881) | |
| Priory Park (1888) |