| Halifax Cup | Merion B (1904) |
| Merion A (1904-1906) | |
| Merion (1904) | |
| Miscellaneous | Merion Summer XI (1896-1901) |
| Philadelphia Veterans (1898-1904) | |
| Merion (1900-1910) | |
| Merion C (1904) | |
| JB Colahan's Veterans XI (1907) | |
| Merion B (1907-1910) | |
| Philadelphia Pilgrims (1909-1910) | |
| Merion Veterans (1909-1910) | |
| All Philadelphia Veterans (1909) |