| Main FC | Cambridge University (1873-1876) |
| Sussex (1873-1883) | |
| Other FC | Marylebone Cricket Club (1874-1883) |
| Gentlemen of England (1874) | |
| Lord Sheffield's XI (1881-1884) | |
| Miscellaneous | Hurstpierpoint College (1871-1872) |
| Gentlemen of Sussex (1871-1889) | |
| GH Longman's XI (1873) | |
| Cambridge University Next XVI (1873) | |
| Cambridge University (1874-1876) | |
| Chichester Priory Park (1874) | |
| Etceteras (1875) | |
| FFJ Greenfield's XI (1876) | |
| United South of England Eleven (1876-1878) | |
| Sussex (1879) | |
| Sheffield Park (1880-1881) | |
| Lewes Priory (1881) | |
| Marylebone Cricket Club (1882-1887) | |
| Clergy (1885) | |
| Lord Sheffield's XI (1886) | |
| The Stoics (1886-1887) | |
| Old Hurst Johnians (1887) |