| Main FC | Surrey (1871-1883) |
| Oxford University (1873-1876) | |
| Other FC | Oxford and Cambridge Universities Past and Present (1874) |
| Marylebone Cricket Club (1883) | |
| Miscellaneous | Sherborne School (1868-1871) |
| Gentlemen of Dorset (1871-1875) | |
| South (1872) | |
| Gentlemen of Surrey (1872) | |
| Mitcham (1872) | |
| WH Game's XI (1873-1876) | |
| Oxford University Freshmen (1873) | |
| Oxford University (1873-1876) | |
| Surrey Club (1873-1875) | |
| Oriel College, Oxford (1874) | |
| Oxford and Cambridge Universities (1874) | |
| Etceteras (1875) | |
| Harlequins (1875-1876) | |
| Esher (1880-1891) | |
| Marylebone Cricket Club (1882-1884) |