| Main FC | Oxford University (1868-1871) |
| Other FC | Gentlemen of England (1872) |
| EJ Sanders' XI (1886) | |
| Miscellaneous | Marlborough College (1865-1866) |
| Gentlemen of Devon (1865-1875) | |
| JB Gilmore's House (1866) | |
| B Pauncefote's XI (1868-1869) | |
| Oxford University Freshmen (1868) | |
| Oxford University Next XVI (1868) | |
| Oxford University (1868-1871) | |
| Etceteras (1869-1870) | |
| Harlequins (1870-1872) | |
| Shillinglee (1874) | |
| Devon (1874-1884) | |
| I Zingari (1875-1885) | |
| Gentlemen of Warwickshire (1878) | |
| Newbury (1879) | |
| Norfolk (1879-1880) | |
| Essex (1882) | |
| EJ Sanders' XI (1886) | |
| Lindum (1887) | |
| Lincolnshire (1889-1894) |