| Main FC | Yorkshire (1862) |
| Yorkshire (1863-1874) | |
| Miscellaneous | Leeds (1853-1863) |
| Bradford (1854-1880) | |
| Wakefield (1857) | |
| All England Eleven (1862-1867) | |
| Gomersal (1863) | |
| Birkenshaw (1863) | |
| Halifax (1863-1864) | |
| Dewsbury (1863) | |
| Morley (1863) | |
| Longsight (1863) | |
| Boston Spa (1863) | |
| Otley (1863) | |
| Harrogate (1863) | |
| United England Eleven (1864-1867) | |
| Thirsk (1865) | |
| Clayton (1865) | |
| Ossett (1866) | |
| Heckmondwike (1866-1868) | |
| Darlington (1866) | |
| Keighley (1866) | |
| Birmingham (1867) | |
| Colts of the North (1875) | |
| Eccleshill (1875) | |
| Veterans of Yorkshire (1876) |