| Main FC | Oxford University (1854-1855) |
| Nottinghamshire (1855) | |
| Other FC | Gentlemen of England (1865) |
| Miscellaneous | Marlborough College (1852) |
| University College, Oxford (1853-1855) | |
| Oxford University (1853-1856) | |
| Old Marlburians (1854) | |
| Magdalen Club (1855) | |
| Pilch and Martin's England XI (1855) | |
| Leicestershire (1855) | |
| Nottingham Commercial Club (1856) | |
| Loughborough (1856-1871) | |
| Brighton College (1859-1860) | |
| EE Bowen's XI (1862-1863) | |
| Civil Service (1862-1869) | |
| CL Bell's Civil Service XI (1866) | |
| Sevenoaks Vine (1866) | |
| Gentlemen of Nottinghamshire (1867) | |
| Harrow Blues (1868) | |
| Marylebone Cricket Club (1869-1873) | |
| CTCM Montgomerie's XI (1876) |