| Other FC | United States of America (1883-1884) |
| Miscellaneous | United States of America (1862-1883) |
| St George's Club of New York (1862-1872) | |
| Philadelphia (1865) | |
| Boston (1868-1892) | |
| America Cricket Clubs (1868) | |
| American Baseball Players (1874) | |
| Boston Baseball XI (1875-1876) | |
| Baseball Players (1879) | |
| Longwood (1880-1893) | |
| Listowel (1883) | |
| Victoria Club of Boston (1883) | |
| Foresters (1884) | |
| CL Bixby's XI (1884) | |
| Married of Longwood Club (1885-1889) | |
| New England (1885-1886) | |
| G Wright's XI (1886) | |
| G Wright's Massachusetts XI (1888) | |
| Boston Athletic Association (1889-1899) | |
| Massachusetts (1889-1895) | |
| All Boston (1892) | |
| Boston and Lowell (1892) | |
| All Massachusetts (1894) | |
| All New York (1894) | |
| JL Chambers' XI (1900) | |
| T Pettitt's XI (1905-1909) |