| Other FC | United States of America (1883) |
| Miscellaneous | Staten Island Cricket Club (1881-1888) |
| All New York (1882-1888) | |
| Staten Island Cricket Club English (1883-1886) | |
| Rest of Staten Island (1883) | |
| CJP Wilson's XI (1883) | |
| United States of America (1883) | |
| Staten Island Cricket Club Second XI (1888) |