| Other FC | Gentlemen of Philadelphia (1898) |
| Halifax Cup | Belmont (1893-1899) |
| Merion (1900-1902) | |
| Miscellaneous | Belmont Second XI (1892-1895) |
| Belmont Juniors (1892-1893) | |
| Belmont Veterans (1892) | |
| Belmont Summer XI (1892-1898) | |
| Belmont Colts (1894) | |
| Belmont (1895-1908) | |
| United States of America (1897-1898) | |
| Philadelphia Colts (1897) | |
| Merion (1900-1902) |