| Other FC | English Residents (1890) |
| Halifax Cup | Belmont (1890-1891) |
| Tioga (1892-1893) | |
| Miscellaneous | Belmont Second XI (1890) |
| Belmont (1890-1891) | |
| Belmont Summer XI (1891) | |
| Chicago Cricket Club (1891-1894) | |
| Tioga (1892-1895) | |
| St George's Club of Chicago (1895) | |
| Pullman (1895) | |
| All Chicago (1895) |