| Other FC | English Residents (1890) |
| Miscellaneous | Kings County (1886) |
| Riverside (1886) | |
| Trenton (1886) | |
| Manhattan (1887-1908) | |
| All New York (1887-1910) | |
| Manhattan Second XI (1889-1900) | |
| Bedford (1889) | |
| New York East (1890) | |
| Hamilton Club (1890) | |
| New Jersey Athletic Club (1892-1894) | |
| New York and District (1893) | |
| Victoria (1894) | |
| Morris Heights (1894) | |
| Brooklyn (1895) | |
| Manhattan Summer XI (1896) | |
| Union County (1896) | |
| Manhattan Captain's XI (1896-1899) | |
| A Smedley's XI (1896) | |
| New York and Metropolitan District Cricket League (1897-1908) | |
| New York Arbroath (1898) | |
| Knickerbocker Athletic Club (1901) | |
| Prospect Park Clubs (1903) | |
| Bound Brook (1906) | |
| Columbia Oval (1907-1909) | |
| New York Veterans (1909-1913) | |
| New York and New Jersey Cricket Association (1910) |