| Other FC | Gentlemen of Philadelphia (1894) |
| Halifax Cup | Philadelphia Cricket Club (1887-1902) |
| Tioga (1890-1896) | |
| Miscellaneous | Quaker City (1883-1887) |
| Quaker City Second XI (1884) | |
| Oxford Second XI (1885) | |
| Merion Veterans (1885) | |
| Oxford (1886) | |
| N Etting's XI (1887) | |
| Philadelphia Cricket Club (1888-1906) | |
| Philadelphia Cricket Club Second XI (1888) | |
| Tioga (1889-1895) | |
| Tioga Athletic Association Summer XI (1892-1893) | |
| EM Cregar's XI (1892) | |
| Halifax Cup Clubs (1893) | |
| GS Patterson's XI (1894) | |
| Germantown Summer XI (1895) | |
| Philadelphia (1898) | |
| Germantown and Philadelphia Cricket Club (1899) | |
| JB Colahan's XI (1899) | |
| Philadelphia Cricket Club Juniors (1901) |