| Other FC | Gentlemen of Philadelphia (1912-1913) |
| Canada and United States of America (1913) | |
| Halifax Cup | Moorestown (1911-1914) |
| Miscellaneous | Haddonfield (1900-1907) |
| Haddonfield Summer XI (1901) | |
| Philadelphia Colts (1905-1909) | |
| Haverford College (1907-1933) | |
| Moorestown (1908-1914) | |
| Gentlemen of Philadelphia (1912) | |
| United States of America (1912) | |
| All Philadelphia (1914-1918) | |
| Philadelphia Pilgrims (1916) | |
| Haverford College Alumni (1938) |