| Other FC | United States of America (1883) |
| Miscellaneous | Peninsular Cricket Club (1877-1889) |
| W White's XI (1878) | |
| Gentlemen of Canada (1880) | |
| Western Association (1882-1886) | |
| Maumee Valley (1883-1885) | |
| United States of America (1883) | |
| West (1887) | |
| Detroit (1889-1892) | |
| Pullman (1890-1891) | |
| DS Lee's XI (1891) | |
| Chicago XVIII (1891) | |
| Chicago (1891) | |
| Detroit Athletic Club (1892-1901) | |
| St Lawrence (1894-1895) |