| Halifax Cup | Germantown (1886-1900) |
| Young America (1888) | |
| Germantown A (1901) | |
| Miscellaneous | Germantown Second XI (1883-1894) |
| Germantown Third XI (1883-1895) | |
| Young America Juniors (1884) | |
| Gentlemen of Leisure (1884) | |
| Chestnut Hill Veterans (1884) | |
| Picked XI (1884) | |
| Germantown (1884-1901) | |
| Germantown Veterans (1885-1886) | |
| Germantown Wanderers (1886) | |
| Young America (1887) | |
| Germantown Zingari (1893-1900) | |
| Germantown Next XVIII (1895) | |
| Germantown Summer XI (1901) |