| Halifax Cup | Manor Field (1919-1920) |
| Miscellaneous | Columbia Oval (1907-1916) |
| Columbia Oval Third XI (1907) | |
| Richmond County (1910-1917) | |
| New York Veterans (1910-1925) | |
| All New York (1912-1928) | |
| All Staten Island (1913) | |
| Manor Field (1917-1925) | |
| Fordham (1927-1928) |