| Liverpool Premier League | New Brighton (1896-1899) |
| Liverpool (1899-1910) | |
| Formby (1902-1903) | |
| Miscellaneous | Seacombe and District (1895) |
| New Brighton (1896-1899) | |
| HHB Hawkins' XI (1899) | |
| RNR Blaker's XI (1900) | |
| PR Johnson's XI (1901) | |
| Cambridge University (1901-1906) | |
| Northern Nomads (1903-1906) | |
| Cambridge University Crusaders (1903-1906) | |
| Liverpool (1904-1906) | |
| Liverpool and District (1904) | |
| AM Sutthery's XI (1906) |