| Yorkshire Premier League | Appleby Frodingham (1999) |
| Miscellaneous | Grimsby Town Second XI (1984-1985) |
| Grimsby Town (1984-1994) | |
| Appleby Frodingham (1995-1999) | |
| Outcasts (2000-2010) | |
| Outcasts Third XI (2001-2003) | |
| Outcasts Second XI (2003-2004) | |
| Appleby Frodingham Second XI (2011) |