| Halifax Cup | Germantown (1884-1888) |
| Merion (1891-1892) | |
| Miscellaneous | Dorian (1882) |
| Dorian Second XI (1882) | |
| Haverford College (1883-1885) | |
| Germantown Second XI (1884) | |
| Incapables (1884) | |
| Germantown (1884-1885) | |
| Cherokees (1884) | |
| Gentlemen of Leisure (1884) | |
| Philadelphia Colts (1884) | |
| Wister's XI (1884) | |
| All Philadelphia (1885) | |
| S Law's XI (1885) | |
| RL Rutter's XI (1885) | |
| United States of America (1885) | |
| FL Baily's XI (1885) | |
| Merion (1890-1892) | |
| Haverford College Sophomores (1893) | |
| Haverford College Third XI (1893) |