| Halifax Cup | Germantown (1880-1888) |
| Miscellaneous | St Paul's School Alumni (1877) |
| Germantown (1877-1902) | |
| Modocs (1877) | |
| Dorian (1877-1878) | |
| Old Haverfordians (1878-1879) | |
| Picked XI (1878) | |
| Haverford College (1880-1881) | |
| Cherokees (1883-1884) | |
| Incapables (1884) | |
| Germantown Veterans (1886-1901) | |
| Germantown Wanderers (1886-1904) | |
| Germantown Second XI (1888-1892) | |
| C Platt's XI (1889) | |
| Germantown Summer XI (1891-1902) | |
| Germantown Third XI (1893-1894) | |
| Germantown Zingari (1894-1901) | |
| Philadelphia Veterans (1898-1903) | |
| G Ashbridge's XI (1912) |