| Halifax Cup | Germantown (1916-1917) |
| Frankford (1919) | |
| Miscellaneous | North End (1890-1892) |
| Oxford (1891) | |
| Fairhill (1891-1894) | |
| Delaware Football Club (1893) | |
| Melrose (1894-1895) | |
| York Road (1895) | |
| Germantown Summer XI (1895-1917) | |
| Albion Club of Philadelphia (1896-1899) | |
| Albion Club of New York (1898) | |
| Wissahickon (1902-1905) | |
| Delaware County Field Club (1903-1908) | |
| Gibbsboro (1904) | |
| Lighthouse (1905-1911) | |
| Delaware County (1906) | |
| Frankford (1908-1919) | |
| Frankford Second XI (1908) | |
| Linden (1908) | |
| Interstate Cricket League of Philadelphia (1910-1921) | |
| West Philadelphia (1910-1911) | |
| E Guest's XI (1911) | |
| Bon Air (1914) | |
| Germantown (1914-1920) | |
| Germantown B (1916) | |
| All Philadelphia (1916-1918) | |
| Associated Cricket Clubs of Philadelphia (1916-1919) | |
| Philadelphia (1917) | |
| Germantown and Philadelphia Cricket Club (1918) | |
| Germantown British Americans (1921) | |
| Ardmore Summer XI (1921) | |
| Ardmore (1922-1924) | |
| Germantown British Americans Juniors (1922) |