| Miscellaneous | Mystic Club of Medford (1887-1893) |
| Lawrence (1888-1889) | |
| Massachusetts (1889-1890) | |
| Medford (1889-1891) | |
| EA Record's XI (1890) | |
| Brooklyn (1891) | |
| CF Villiers' XI (1892) | |
| Mystic Club of Medford Second XI (1892) | |
| Boston Zingari (1895-1902) | |
| R Turner's XI (1896) | |
| Boston District (1896) | |
| Newton (1897) | |
| Boston Cricket Club (1897-1899) | |
| Boston Cricket Club Second XI (1897) | |
| EP Greaves' XI (1897-1902) | |
| Brockton (1898) | |
| W Pickering's XI (1898) | |
| All Massachusetts (1898) | |
| Boston Wanderers (1899) | |
| Boston Incognitos (1901) | |
| Roxbury (1901-1902) |