| Miscellaneous | Upper Canada College Second XI (1885-1886) |
| Hamilton (1885-1899) | |
| Upper Canada College (1886) | |
| University of Trinity College (1887-1899) | |
| Hamilton Juniors (1887-1892) | |
| Hamilton Colts (1888-1889) | |
| Toronto and Hamilton (1888) | |
| Upper Canada College Past and Present (1889-1892) | |
| Rosedale (1890-1891) | |
| Upper Canada College Old Boys (1892) | |
| East Toronto (1894) | |
| Canada (1894) | |
| Ontario (1895) | |
| Martins XI (1895) |