| Miscellaneous | South Brooklyn (1891-1893) |
| South Brooklyn Second XI (1893) | |
| Columbia Oval (1894) | |
| Manhattan Third XI (1894) | |
| Manhattan Second XI (1894) | |
| TB Bowen's XI (1894) | |
| Columbia Oval Second XI (1894) | |
| Manhattan Veterans (1896) | |
| Manhattan Captain's XI (1896) |