| Main FC | Jamaica (1908/09-1927/28) |
| Other FC | West Indians (1906) |
| WG Grace's XI (1907) | |
| Gentlemen of England (1908) | |
| Miscellaneous | Canada (1905) |
| West Indians (1906) | |
| London County (1907-1908) | |
| Jamaica North and South Side (1908/09) | |
| Jamaica (1910/11) | |
| Jamaica Colts (1926/27) | |
| Kensington Park (1938) |